ICP and targeting
Searching for 'VP Sales' and exporting the results misses many of the right people and catches plenty of the wrong ones. Here's a method that starts from the problem and ends with a verified list.
By Satvik Luthra, Founder11 October 20269 min read
Key takeaways
To find the right decision-makers at a target account, start from the problem you solve, work out which roles own that problem and its budget, then turn those roles into a list of titles by function and seniority, including common variations and explicit exclusions. Verify every contact before anything is sent.
Most outbound lists are built the other way around: someone types "VP Sales" into a search filter and exports whatever comes back. That catches some of the right people, misses many who hold the same responsibility under a different title, and includes plenty who have no say in the purchase. This guide walks through a more reliable method, with a worked example you can adapt.
"Decision-maker" is a convenient shorthand, but very few B2B purchases are decided by one person. In practice you are looking for a small set of people with different stakes in the same decision:
For cold outreach, your first message usually goes to one of the first two: the person who feels the problem sharply and has enough authority to take a meeting. The others come into the conversation later, often introduced by your champion.
Before you open any database, write one sentence describing the problem you solve in the customer's terms. For example: "Month-end close takes too long because supplier invoices are matched by hand." Then ask three questions:
The answers give you roles, not titles. In the example above: the person measured on close speed is the controller or head of finance, the budget sits with the CFO or VP Finance, and the work is done by the accounts payable team. Titles come next.
Look at your last ten to twenty won deals and note who played each role. If you don't have that many, look at deals that reached a late stage. Patterns appear quickly. You might find that the first conversation almost always started with a director, that the CFO joined only for the final call, and that IT reviewed the security questionnaire but never objected.
That tells you whom to email first, whom to mention by role in later emails, and whom you don't need to contact at all. Record it in a simple grid of role, typical title, what they care about and when they join the deal. You will reuse it for every campaign.
Now convert roles into titles along two axes: function (the department) and seniority (the level). Keeping these separate makes your list easier to adjust later. If replies show that directors respond but VPs don't, you change one setting rather than rewriting the whole list.
| Seniority | Typical titles (finance function) | Role in the deal |
|---|---|---|
| C-level | CFO, Chief Financial Officer | Signer or budget owner |
| VP | VP Finance, VP Financial Operations | Budget owner; often the best first contact in larger companies |
| Director / Head | Finance Director, Head of Finance, Controller | Problem owner; strong first contact in mid-sized companies |
| Manager | AP Manager, Accounting Manager | Day-to-day user; useful for research and later stages |
| Individual contributor | AP Specialist, Staff Accountant | Usually excluded from first outreach |
Pick one or two seniority levels per function for your first contact. Reaching too high wastes a message on someone who will never read it. Reaching too low puts your email in front of someone without the authority to act.
The same job carries different titles in different companies, industries and countries. If your list only matches exact titles, you will miss a large share of the people you want. Build a variation list for every core title:
Decide which modifiers you want. "Interim CFO" may be a great contact if new leaders are a buying trigger for you. "Fractional CFO" usually means an external advisor who serves several companies, which might be a separate audience entirely.
Exclusions keep your list clean. Without them, keyword-based title matching pulls in people who share a word with your target title but do a different job. Typical exclusions:
Review the first few hundred matches by hand and add an exclusion every time you find a mismatch. Twenty minutes of review here saves many wasted emails later.
The right first contact changes with company size. A useful rule of thumb is to move one seniority level down as companies get larger:
| Company size | Who usually owns the problem | Suggested first contact |
|---|---|---|
| Under 50 employees | Founder or a generalist operator | Founder, CEO or COO |
| 51 to 200 | Functional head, often one level from the CEO | Head of, VP or Director |
| 201 to 1,000 | Director or VP with a team | Director or VP |
| Over 1,000 | Director or senior manager for the specific area | Director, Senior Manager or Head of a sub-function |
Treat this as a starting point, not a law. Your won-deal analysis should override it whenever the two disagree.
A perfect title list is worthless if the contact data is stale. People change jobs, companies rename roles and email addresses stop working. Before any contact goes into a campaign, check:
Then look at a sample of each list as a person would. If a contact looks wrong to you, it will look wrong to them. RevFirst handles this step by preparing verified contacts for each campaign and letting you keep or remove individual leads before anything is sent.
Here is a complete map for a fictional company, Ledgerly, which sells accounts payable software to mid-market companies. Use the same columns for your own product.
| Role | Function | Seniority | Core titles | Variations to include | Exclude |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Problem owner (first contact) | Finance | Director / Head | Controller, Finance Director, Head of Finance | Financial Controller, Corporate Controller, Director of Finance, Group Controller | Assistant Controller, Controller of a single plant (if group-level is the target) |
| Budget owner | Finance | VP / C-level | VP Finance, CFO | Chief Financial Officer, Interim CFO, SVP Finance | Fractional CFO, CFO Advisor |
| Day-to-day user | Finance | Manager | AP Manager, Accounting Manager | Accounts Payable Lead, Payables Supervisor | AP Clerk, AP Specialist, Intern |
| Evaluator | IT | Director / Manager | IT Director, Head of IT | Director of Business Systems, ERP Manager | IT Support, Help Desk |
| Signer | Executive | C-level | CFO or CEO | Managing Director | Board members, investors |
With this map, Ledgerly's first campaign would write to controllers and finance directors at 200 to 1,000 person companies, mention the AP team's workload in the email body, and leave the CFO and IT for later in the conversation.
Template: your decision-maker map
For each role write: Role in the deal | Function | Seniority | Core titles | Variations | Exclusions | What they care about | When they join. Fill it from your won deals first, then from research.
Once the map is built, keep it next to your ideal customer profile and update both together. When replies come in, note which titles responded and which didn't. After a few campaigns, your title list will reflect who actually buys, not who you guessed would.
Free Forever plan
RevFirst suggests decision-makers by function and seniority, matches close title variations and lets you exclude roles. Get started for free.